Jun 22, 2010 - About, Events, Rants    7 Comments

Book Shelved

My die guy friend and loyal reader of past articles and current blog posts, Greg from Spaulding & Day Tool & Die emailed me a question yesterday.

He responded with a “thanks” email and suggested I write a book on modern die practices, mainly because the books out there now are quite dated and have, for the most part, lost their relevance due to transfer presses, solid modeling, and NC machining.

Most of you do not know the story, so I agreed to share it here.

Last summer, I gave away all my die books to Eric Kam. Except one: the one I wrote.

That’s right. I wrote a treatise on modern die engineering and construction theory and practice. It was ready to be published in 1999.

As with all my other attempts at finding a need and filling it, the venture fell short because of factors beyond my control.

At the time, I was writing for FMA as a columnist in Stamping Journal and occasional contributor to The Fabricator.

My vision was to create an elegant book. It had to be hardcover with lots of stunning 3D full color graphics. I wanted it to be the best looking book on dies ever published with relevant, easy to understand content.

In my mind, the best publisher to put out this level of quality was FMA.

They gave me a contract – probably the most lucrative contract a first time author ever had. I gave them the manuscript.

A few months into the project, the entire editorial staff bailed for a dot com startup that promised to triple their salaries.

My book instantly died and their new careers lasted only six months.

I talked to PMA, but that went nowhere fast.

Then, the SME came along. They wanted to publish the same garbage that is out there now – old content (they wanted to borrow material from their other books and use cheap black and white 2D drawings).

At this point, I have about 5,000 hours of writing time and a couple years effort invested to find a publisher. We come to a half-assed agreement and get started.

The book was going to be a stripped down version of what I had. We were going to put out a book on transfer dies only, then revamp their Die Design Handbook, then rewrite their Progressive Dies book.

This lasted about a month.

The economy tanked and they shut down their new book publishing operations.

Not one to give up easily or when I should, I pressed on and talked to a few more publishers.

They were all the same. The publishers wanted to put out what I considered to be junk and give me a 3% royalty. No thanks.

It was not the money. It was the quality. It had to be the best or be nothing.

I chose nothing.

Actually, I did pursue self-publishing so I could control the quality, but I did not have the distribution channel.

So, I decided to turn some of the content in this spiral bound manuscript into articles for MetalForming magazine.

Perhaps I should update the work and try to get it published. I don’t know. I barely have time to blog anymore.

The book is here and chock full of cool content. It sits in my desk drawer, always within arm’s reach, simply titled Die Theory & Practice: Engineering and Manufacturing Production Stamping Tools.

It is book shelved, just sitting here waiting to be read. All 20 chapters and 500 pages of it.

Alltop, confirmation that I kick ass

7 Comments

  • It is such as waste to see the whole pile of information sitting on your table. When it comes to publishing, publishers are looking for books that will help them print money.

    Why don’t you sell your book online? A friend of mine previously purchased a book on ice-cream making. The book is printed on a laser jet and bound neatly. You can use all your existing stamping buddies to help promote your book. Maybe you would need to invest in a laser jet printer and then sent the books to a shop for binding.

    If you intend to do so, please let me know as I am interested in ordering one. I had enough of stale information from a book title “Handbook of Die Design” written in the 90s *yucks*

    Best wishes,
    Danny Ng
    Malaysia

  • Agree wholeheartedly w/ Danny; offering the book for sale via the Die Guy blog, printed on a laser jet. I know several people that would be interested in something like this.

  • Timmy,

    get the book out. Self publishing has changed a bit lately. http://www.createspace.com is an Amazon Channel. I think if you don’t use their editorial services, or their graphics department there is no set-up cost. you define the royalty since you set the price.

    But, book is static; the diejedi.com and diestandards.com was the way to go. Anyhoo, your books are still in the office if you like. I hardly get to use them, they are too heavy to pack. But I could check diejedi anywhere.

  • Thanks for the support everyone … gives me something to think about. Not sure what I will do with the book or diejedi.com.

    Now that I am just about settled into new digs in Michigan that do not involve vans or rivers, I will put some good thought into where to go next on this.

    Like I said, some has been “re-painted” as articles and blog posts – but I know that is not the same.

  • Tim,

    Your work would be of great value to the industry. I hope you find a way to get it published and/or distributed, especially since the work is done.
    The best die book ever, would be relavent, engineering based and and easy to comprehend. It would not be a “how to” book; it would be a book about “why” we need to engineer dies in a certain manner for a given process or product geometry. Personally, I would sacrifice having stunning pictures in an elegant hardcover book for the most relevant engineering and die-manufacturing information available in any format I could get it in. Whatever you do, don’t let the work waste away in a desk drawer.

    Keep up the good work. You and Eric Kamm do a great job getting relevant information out on the net. Thanks for sharing with us.

    Pete Ulintz

  • Thanks Pete … you are right.

    I think what I have would need to be tweaked a bit, but right now I believe it does express the whys and not necessarily the hows … and at the same time, applies to all materials and not written specifically for SAE 1008-1010 like the books from the ’60s were.

  • Just stopping by to praise you for the great read. It was really worth my time reading this post. Hoping for more wonderful content soon! I added your feed in my reader!

Got anything to say? Go ahead and leave a comment!